Michael McCoy


M: 614-395-4987

Contact Me

Make Preferred Realtor
Michael McCoy - Cutler Real Estate Agent


Buyer's Agent, Condominiums, Listing Agent, Luxury Homes, Multifamily, New Construction, Relocation, Rentals, Residential



95 E Deshler Avenue
Columbus, OH 43206

5 beds 4 bath 2,524 sqft

11166 Jerome Road
Plain City, OH 43064

4 beds 4 bath 2,400 sqft


German Village, OH

Located just south of downtown Columbus, German Village is a charming neighborhood boasting historic homes, quaint local shops and eateries, and brick sidewalks and streets. This historic neighborhood is one of the most renowned communities in the country. Real Estate Featuring sturdy, red-brick homes along tree-lined brick streets, German Village is a desirable neighborhood to call home. Homes in German Village are typically situated close together on narrow plots with small yards. Due to the neighborhood’s charm and central...

Learn More
German Village - Photo 1
5/5 Based on 5 Ratings
Add Testimonial
5/5 Based on 20 Ratings
View More Testimonials on Agent Site
Sep 13, 2019

Mike was amazing and made my house hunting experience fun and relaxing. There was never any pressure and he was available and assisted me throughout every step, even after closing. Best agent I have ever worked with!!

— Maria Sass
Nov 20, 2017

Michael sold our home in Lewis center in less than two weeks and helped us find our dream condo in Harrison West with all the amenities we could possibly want and more. Michael is very perceptive and after spending just a short period of time with us,, he was able to tell exactly what we were looking for and worked hard to find it for us. He found our condo in an area he felt the market was on the rise,, so when we were ready to sell we could do so for a profit. , We recently had to sell our condo to move out of state for work and didn't think twice about hiring Michael again to sell our home. Michael has such a great knowledge of the market and was able to sell our condo in under a week! He is always readily available and kept us well informed during the entire process. Both times Michael has sold our homes he used his ineffable marketing skills to sell our homes at top market value. We recommend Michael with highest regards and if we ever end up in the Columbus area we know who we will call.

— Jennifer and Derek Adams SELLER
Nov 20, 2017

We are so grateful to have found Michael after many other negative experiences with other agents. We were looking in a very limited time-frame and he was able to accommodate and help us find our home. He even helped us find temporary housing until our deal closed. We are very particular and Michael is very detail oriented. He had answers to all our questions and always was working on our side. There was never any doubt that he would find us our home,, despite how particular we are. Thank you,, Michael!

— Dr. Patrick and Laura Youssef BUYER
Nov 20, 2017

Michael is a fantastic Realtor who goes out of his way to serve his clients' needs. He is available any time and has made himself available to us at a moment's notice. He is friendly,, helpful,, very knowledgeable,, and was a wonderful resource as we have gone through the process of buying and selling houses in the last few years.

— Dr. Amy Pyle-Eilola BUYER
Nov 20, 2017

Michael McCoy was instrumental in both the sale of our old home and the purchase of our new home. Michael is a very active realtor whose pulse on the market and familiarity with the desired location helped tremendously. I really appreciated how he was able to get a great sense of what our goals were by asking the right questions and focusing on the right things. Once things got moving on the buy & sell side,, he was quick to not only facilitate the process,, but make sure it went smoothly,, especially for us. At no point did we feel like he was pressuring us to transact for the sake of transacting,, but really aiding us in helping us find a home. I would highly recommend him to anyone who's looking for an agent who has their best interest in mind,, who is technologically savvy,, and is always available to take your call or reply to your e-mail.

— Eric & Rebecca Liu SELLER & BUYER
Mar 4, 2019

Michael is a truly wonderful realtor, who will undoubtedly become your friend by the end of your journey. He has the ability to make this process enjoyable through his patience, round-the-clock service, and outstanding sense of humor. He makes himself readily available via telephone, email or text message. He will do showings via FaceTime if you need him to. He was incredibly patient with us bringing our toddler on a full day of home showings. He listens to what you want and helps envision your dreams in homes that most people would pass over. Say you don't want to live near a cell tower; he will make sure he is not wasting your time with showings that fall in that category. He is always willing to go the extra mile, even if that means sending letters to homes in a neighborhood you are targeting. As a Columbus native and property owner, he understands the progression of the city and how certain areas are evolving to help you truly choose the right area to call home. He is also incredibly connected in contractors to help you renovate your home to meet your needs. His recommendations for restaurants, doctors... everything are thorough and very helpful when you are moving to the area from out of state. When you tell someone that Michael McCoy sent you, you are warmly welcomed and you can understand why everyone has the utmost respect and fondness for him. We highly recommend him!

Jul 31, 2018

My wife and I recently relocated from Texas and Mike made the process of finding a new home seamless. Mike was honest, had great insight into the market, and did everything in his power to ensure we found the right home. Also, once we closed, Mike was able to provide great referrals to assist with the renovations needed. I'd highly recommend Mike to anyone and have confidence he would do a great job.

— whodey329
Apr 30, 2018

We utilized Michael for a recent home purchase and could not have been more pleased with his level of knowledge and service. Michael is professional and personable. He was very patient and kind with our two young children while showing us numerous houses until we found the one that was right for us. He was forthright in his recommendations and the process to close was incredibly smooth. I would highly recommend Michael to a friend or family member without any reservations.

— BenjaminCHaas
Apr 25, 2018

Mike is the BEST! He's worked with us 3 projects now. He's attentive, smart, knowledgeable and highly respected in his field. He adapts to changes and takes everything in stride. I've recommended him to a good friend who has a high end property to sell. He coordinated the repair work, refinished floors, painting and staging. She's out of state and couldn't have done it without him. Mike's got amazing resources to share and only accepts the best in quality and performance. I regard him as a friend and would use him again in a heartbeat! He's got great taste and is as honorable as they come. I wouldn't use anyone else!

— joannbmartin56
Apr 11, 2018

We absolutely love our home and we simply would not be in our home (or Upper Arlington for that matter - our desired locale) without Mike McCoy. Mike is very personable, professional, impressively responsive, and was very proactive in our house hunt. To prove this point, we lived 3 hours away during this process and Mike arranged a mid-week 'viewing' over Facetime the day the house was listed. Following Mike's advice, we offered that very night and entered agreement the next morning - only to find out that we had beat out 4 other offers that came the day after ours. We highly recommend Mike McCoy without reservation and plan to ask him to help us with our next home.

— user35515636
Apr 6, 2018

We were fortunate to have met Mike at an Open House while my family was looking to purchase a new home. Immediately we discovered that we had excellent report and quickly found out that we had made a great decision to work with him. The most notable characteristic about Mike is his work-style. He doesn't make you feel rushed or hurried during any part of the buy/sell process. He was open & honest throughout. He kept us grounded and focused on our "must-haves". I'm not sure how many other clients he was working with at the time, but not once did we feel as though we were not being attended to. He's very in touch with the market and has great connections/relationships that he's worked diligently to develop. Most importantly, he stayed actively engaged after contracts were signed and didn't leave us hanging. I highly recommend Mike McCoy to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and dedicated agent who puts his clients' interests first.

— user7666547
Mar 28, 2018

Mike is a realtor that truly cares about his clients and has their best interests in mind. My wife and I have used him to sell 2 homes and buy 1. Mike surprised us with significantly higher than expected sale prices on both homes he sold for us. I would highly recommend him and look forward to using him again in the future.

— Derek Adams
Mar 27, 2018

Michael has been wonderful to work with. He has helped us buy and sell a home, both of which were extremely positive experiences with him. He knows the Columbus market very well. I would highly recommend Michael!

— Whitney
Mar 27, 2018

My husband and I have used Mike in both the buying and selling capacity. He sold our home in the suburbs, and helped us find exactly what we were looking for in downtown living in Columbus. Our house sold in less than two weeks!! Mike was very knowledgeable of the downtown area, and got to know us on a personal level so he could find us the perfect home. When we had to move out of state for work, he sold our condo in 5 days!! We couldn't be happier with our experience with Mike.

— davernjn
Mar 26, 2018

Mike is fantastic at what he does. He was extremely knowledgeable, responsive and patient during the entire buying process. We trusted his advice and insight and couldn't be happier with our home which we got at an amazing value. We were so happy with Mike that we insisted that my sister and brother-in-law work with him on finding a home as they move back to Columbus. Mike is a true advocate for his clients which is demonstrated by his results.

— elwadlinger
View More Testimonials on Agent Site