If you're one of the thousands of homebuyers waiting for rates to fall, you should know it's already happening. And they recently crossed an important milestone. Rates officially dipped their toes into the 5s...
Designations ?
- ABR®Accredited Buyer's Representative®
- ALCAccredited Land Consultant
- ASPAccredited Staging Professional®
- AHWDAt Home With Diversity
- AHWD®At Home With Diversity®
- CCIMCertified Commercial Investment Member
- CDPECertified Distressed Property Expert®
- CIDCertified Interior Decorator
- CIPSCertified International Property Specialist
- CIASCertified Investor Agent Specialist
- CNECertified Negotiation Expert
- CPM®Certified Property Manager®
- CRBCertified Real Estate Brokerage Manager
- CRENCertified Real Estate Negotiator
- CRETSCertified Real Estate Team Specialist
- CRSCertified Residential Specialist
- CRE™Counselor of Real Estate™
- GAAGeneral Accredited Appraiser
- GRIGraduate, REALTOR® Institute
- HHSHistoric House Specialist
- MBAMaster of Business Administration
- MRPMilitary Relocation Professional
- GREENNAR's Green Designation
- e-PRO®NAR's real estate technology certification
- PMNPerformance Management Network
- PSAProperty Strategy Advisor
- RCEREALTOR® Association Certified Executive
- RAAResidential Accredited Appraiser
- RSPSResort & Second-Home Property Specialist
- SRSSeller Representative Specialist
- SRES®Seniors Real Estate Specialist®
- SFR®Short Sales & Foreclosure Resource®
- SIORSociety of Industrial and Office REALTORS®
NINJA CERTIFIED™
SpecialtiesBuyer's Agent, Condominiums, Listing Agent, Luxury Homes, Multifamily, New Construction, Relocation, Rentals, Residential
I am passionate about delivering exceptional consumer experiences. By offering a complete suite of real estate services, I ensure that I meet my consumers' every need. From sales and rentals, to mortgage, design, contractors, and title insurance, I have experts in every field to guide you skillfully from beginning to the end of your real estate journey. With over a decade of experience in residential real estate, including invaluable New York City experience, I have marketing and negotiating skills that produce the highest rate of success in arranging transactions for clients. Further, I share a commitment to discretion that is absolute. When you hire me, you get direct access to me. You're not hiring my assistant or a buyer's agent. What you will receive is a team of professionals working behind the scenes. This starts with our full-service in-house marketing team dedicated to the delivery of solutions tailored to my exclusive listings. What does this mean to you? These combined efforts and experience translate to real returns and a better bottom line for my clients. You can feel comfortable knowing you have a true professional in your corner.
Michael McCoy brings over twelve years of successful real estate sales experience to Cutler Real Estate. His previous experience includes being an associate of one of "The Wall Street Journal/REAL Trend's Top 250 Teams in the United States". In addition to his work in Columbus, Michael worked for one of the most highly respected residential brokerage firms in New York City, Halstead Property. Equally comfortable working with buyers and sellers, Michael's professional manner is evident throughout every phase of a real estate transaction. He is an expert in the relocation process, recognizing the unique financial and emotional challenges clients face during their transition. An owner of multiple investment properties throughout the downtown neighborhoods of the city, he appreciates the expectations and goals investors often must find.
Michael is 100% committed to his craft aggressively working seven days a week to stay on top of the market finding exclusive opportunities for his clients. Respected by both fellow agents and repeat customers, he is known for gently navigating his clients through the transaction.
Michael grew up in Upper Arlington, Ohio. He holds a BA from The Ohio State University with a focus in Marketing and Sociology. An avid traveler, Michael prefers to be outside, whether it's a run around German Village, brunch at an outdoor café, or admiring the architecture of the historical neighborhoods of Columbus and abroad. Michael is a member of the German Village Society, The Athletic Club of Columbus, Downtown Residents' Association of Columbus, among other organizations. Michael is a licensed real estate salesperson in both Ohio and New York.
Featured Listings
$1,995.00
Active
432 E Rich Street
Columbus, OH 43215 1 beds 1 full/1 half baths 1,329 sqft mls 226003897
$4,500.00
Active
4260 Reedbury Lane
Columbus, OH 43220 4 beds 3 full/1 half baths 3,906 sqft mls 225040794
$689,900
Active
424 Jackson Street
Columbus, OH 43206 2 beds 2 full/1 half baths 1,686 sqft mls 226002593
Columbus, OH 43215 1 beds 1 full/1 half baths 1,329 sqft mls 226003897
$4,500.00
Active
4260 Reedbury LaneColumbus, OH 43220 4 beds 3 full/1 half baths 3,906 sqft mls 225040794
$689,900
Active
424 Jackson StreetColumbus, OH 43206 2 beds 2 full/1 half baths 1,686 sqft mls 226002593
$380,000
Closed
Listed at $375,000
696 Tree Bend Court
Westerville, OH 43082 4 beds 3.1 baths 2,331 sqft mls 226006507 Seller Represented $785,000 Closed Listed at $809,900 598 Lathrop Street
Columbus, OH 43206 2 beds 2.1 baths 2,156 sqft mls 225038622 Buyer Represented $2,500 Closed Listed at $0 801 S Front Street
Columbus, OH 43206 2 beds 3.1 baths 1,600 sqft mls 225042766 Both Represented
Westerville, OH 43082 4 beds 3.1 baths 2,331 sqft mls 226006507 Seller Represented $785,000 Closed Listed at $809,900 598 Lathrop Street
Columbus, OH 43206 2 beds 2.1 baths 2,156 sqft mls 225038622 Buyer Represented $2,500 Closed Listed at $0 801 S Front Street
Columbus, OH 43206 2 beds 3.1 baths 1,600 sqft mls 225042766 Both Represented
See What People Are Saying About Me
Brinn Mitchell
Mike was great and made the whole experience easier and fun.
Mike was great and made the whole experience easier and fun.
Christian Mitchell
Mike McCoy was a great resource through every step of our buying process. He was always available to us and made the process smooth and easy. He came highly recommended to us and he did not disappoint!
Mike McCoy was a great resource through every step of our buying process. He was always available to us and made the process smooth and easy. He came highly recommended to us and he did not disappoint!
Dr. Amy Pyle-Eilola
Michael is a fantastic Realtor who goes out of his way to serve his clients' needs. He is available any time and has made himself available to us at a moment's notice. He is friendly,, helpful,, very knowledgeable,, and was a wonderful res...keep reading
Michael is a fantastic Realtor who goes out of his way to serve his clients' needs. He is available any time and has made himself available to us at a moment's notice. He is friendly,, helpful,, very knowledgeable,, and was a wonderful resource as we have gone through the process of buying and selling houses in the last few years.
Eric & Rebecca Liu
Michael McCoy was instrumental in both the sale of our old home and the purchase of our new home. Michael is a very active realtor whose pulse on the market and familiarity with the desired location helped tremendously. I really appreciated how he ...keep reading
Michael McCoy was instrumental in both the sale of our old home and the purchase of our new home. Michael is a very active realtor whose pulse on the market and familiarity with the desired location helped tremendously. I really appreciated how he was able to get a great sense of what our goals were by asking the right questions and focusing on the right things. Once things got moving on the buy & sell side,, he was quick to not only facilitate the process,, but make sure it went smoothly,, especially for us. At no point did we feel like he was pressuring us to transact for the sake of transacting,, but really aiding us in helping us find a home. I would highly recommend him to anyone who's looking for an agent who has their best interest in mind,, who is technologically savvy,, and is always available to take your call or reply to your e-mail.
Jennifer and Derek Adams
Michael sold our home in Lewis center in less than two weeks and helped us find our dream condo in Harrison West with all the amenities we could possibly want and more. Michael is very perceptive and after spending just a short period of time with u...keep reading
Michael sold our home in Lewis center in less than two weeks and helped us find our dream condo in Harrison West with all the amenities we could possibly want and more. Michael is very perceptive and after spending just a short period of time with us,, he was able to tell exactly what we were looking for and worked hard to find it for us. He found our condo in an area he felt the market was on the rise,, so when we were ready to sell we could do so for a profit. ,
We recently had to sell our condo to move out of state for work and didn't think twice about hiring Michael again to sell our home. Michael has such a great knowledge of the market and was able to sell our condo in under a week! He is always readily available and kept us well informed during the entire process. Both times Michael has sold our homes he used his ineffable marketing skills to sell our homes at top market value. We recommend Michael with highest regards and if we ever end up in the Columbus area we know who we will call.
Maria Sass
Mike was amazing and made my house hunting experience fun and relaxing. There was never any pressure and he was available and assisted me throughout every step, even after closing. Best agent I have ever worked with!!
Luis Gonzalez
Mike is very friendly and listened to our wants for our home.
Dr. Patrick and Laura Youssef
We are so grateful to have found Michael after many other negative experiences with other agents. We were looking in a very limited time-frame and he was able to accommodate and help us find our home. He even helped us find temporary housing until ...keep reading
We are so grateful to have found Michael after many other negative experiences with other agents. We were looking in a very limited time-frame and he was able to accommodate and help us find our home. He even helped us find temporary housing until our deal closed. We are very particular and Michael is very detail oriented. He had answers to all our questions and always was working on our side. There was never any doubt that he would find us our home,, despite how particular we are. Thank you,, Michael!
Mike is very friendly and listened to our wants for our home.
Mike was amazing and made my house hunting experience fun and relaxing. There was never any pressure and he was available and assisted me throughout every step, even after closing. Best agent I have ever worked with!!
Michael sold our home in Lewis center in less than two weeks and helped us find our dream condo in Harrison West with all the amenities we could possibly want and more. Michael is very perceptive and after spending just a short period of time with u...keep reading
Michael sold our home in Lewis center in less than two weeks and helped us find our dream condo in Harrison West with all the amenities we could possibly want and more. Michael is very perceptive and after spending just a short period of time with us,, he was able to tell exactly what we were looking for and worked hard to find it for us. He found our condo in an area he felt the market was on the rise,, so when we were ready to sell we could do so for a profit. ,
We recently had to sell our condo to move out of state for work and didn't think twice about hiring Michael again to sell our home. Michael has such a great knowledge of the market and was able to sell our condo in under a week! He is always readily available and kept us well informed during the entire process. Both times Michael has sold our homes he used his ineffable marketing skills to sell our homes at top market value. We recommend Michael with highest regards and if we ever end up in the Columbus area we know who we will call.
Property Alerts
Finding your next home just got easier. Save custom searches and get email alerts for new listings that come on the market.
Orange + Blue
Mortgage Rates Recently Hit a 3-Year Low. Here's Why That's Still a Big Deal.January 28, 2026
The Cutler Real Estate® word mark is a registered trademark owned by Cutler and Associates, Inc.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility
This site is hosted, designed and copyright
© 1994 - 2026 by
Delta Media Group, Inc. -- Patent Pending --